I agree completely. Although some lists at this time of year will look more at popularity than quality (of course the two are not mutually exclusive), I'm much more interested in the latter. But here's the thing - looking at the list created by the Amazon editors (who had meetings and discussions about what were the 'best' books in various categories in their eyes), it's pretty clear they have felt the same. Whether you agree with their choices or not - and let's be honest, that's half the fun with these things, having the debate and chatting about other great books too - I think it's pretty clear they've thought about this with little regard to sales figures. There's not a Lee Child or James Patterson book to be seen, amongst many other big-sellers.
So, let's get to it. In the eyes of the Amazon Editors, these were the Top 10 Mystery, Thriller, and Suspense Books of 2012:
- GONE GIRL by Gillian Flynn
- SWEET TOOTH by Ian McEwan
- LIVE BY NIGHT by Dennis Lehane
- PHANTOM by Jo Nesbo
- DEFENDING JACOB by William Landay
- BROKEN HARBOUR by Tana French
- CREOLE BELLE by James Lee Burke
- MAY WE BE FORGIVEN by AM Homes
- AFTERWARDS by Rosamund Lupton
- THE THIEF by Fuminori Nakamura
At first glance, it seems a pretty good list. I'm sure there are lots of other books many of you think you should be on it instead of some above, but I can't see any completely obvious 'what the heck?' clangers or things that make me think the editors have focussed on sales or anything. The two books on the list that I've personally read this year, PHANTOM and CREOLE BELLE, were amongst the very best books I've read all year, and I would have them somewhere on any 'best of' list I was doing.
I've heard absolutely terrific things about GONE GIRL and BROKEN HARBOUR too (both are staring at me from my TBR pile), and I've read and really enjoyed Flynn's earlier books, which I thought were terrific (and I've heard that GONE GIRL is even a step up from them).
Incidentally, GONE GIRL placed at #3 on the Amazon Editors' overall Top 10 books of any kind list.
So all in all, not a bad list to kickstart things. It will be interesting to see what books feature consistently in various lists from various critics and publications etc over the next few weeks - and which 'hidden gems' others have overlooked sneak through now and then too.
What are some of your favourite books of 2012? Have you read any of the above? What are your thoughts?