Thursday, August 6, 2015


TIED UP IN TINSEL by Ngaio Marsh (Collins Crime Club, 1972)

Reviewed by Kerrie Smith (Fontana edition, 1994)

Every member of the staff at Halberds, but one, is a convicted murderer.

Troy Alleyn, wife of DI Roderick Alleyn of Scotland Yard, is spending Christmas there, her husband out of the country. She is painting the portrait of Hilary Bill-Tasman, the rather eccentric and enormously wealthy landed proprietor of Halberds Manor.

The other members of the Halberds Christmas houseparty - Hilary's Aunt Bed and Uncle Flea, his uncle Bert, and his fiance Cressida Tottenham - round out a rather unusual cast of characters.

Bill-Tasman has organised an elaborate Christmas Day treat for local children in which an ancient bewhiskered and bearded Druid arrives towing a sledge of presents. But after the event the Druid can't be found, and other pranks seem designed to cast the blame for his disappearance on the murderous staff.

Enter Roderick Alleyn just returned from Australia.

Tied Up in Tinsel was among the last of Dame Ngaio Marsh's (1895-1982) mysteries, although she continued to publish another five titles, right up to her death. It reflects not only her gift for clever plotting but also has a very theatrical feel to it. Characteristically, an early page displays a very useful cast of characters, and the whole story feels as if it could easily be dramatised. There are lots of places that have the reader grasping at straws in an attempt to solve the murder before Alleyn does. I must confess that the "how" was easier to deduce than the "why".

I had intended to use this title as my "New Zealand" offering in a Global Reading Challenge, but decided not to since Tied Up In Tinsel is set entirely at an English manor. It is really a variant of a locked room mystery since for much of the time the characters are confined to the manor either by events or by the weather.

Tied Up in Tinsel proves that even as she approached her 80s New Zealand's Dame Ngaio Marsh had not lost her ability to write a good yarn.


Kerrie Smith is a renowned Australian crime fiction reviewer and the creator of Mysteries in Paradise, an outstanding online crime fiction resource where this review was originally published. She also runs the Global Reading Challenge. Kerrie has been kindly agreed to share her New Zealand crime fiction reviews here with the Crime Watch audience.  


1 comment:

  1. Thanks, Kerrie and Crine Watch for an excellent summing up of a Dame Ngaio classic. I've just finished listening to Enter a Murderer on audible, and am about to start Tied up in Tinsel, so this is very timely reminder of the plot. I love listening to these classic whodunnits while working outside in the garden. And while they are a tad old fashioned (and all that goes with that) they're still gems, especially Dame Ngaio's.